Four downtown kitchens are dark right now, and each one has a date to reopen. According to the Town of Nantucket's weekly restaurant sheet, updated October 23, Billie's on Broad comes back November 11, Boarding House and The Pearl return together on November 18, and Ethos Wine Bar & Bistro reopens November 24. Downtown spends the off-season on a relay. The dates are spread a week apart, and the last one falls on the day the Nantucket Historical Association opens its Festival of Wreaths on Straight Wharf in a building most islanders have never been inside.
The stretch between now and the Christmas Stroll comes down to two things: knowing the order of those reopenings, and knowing which kitchens cover the gaps. Most of those kitchens are mid-island.
The order the doors reopen
The Town's sheet is a snapshot of a single week. It isn't a promise of winter hours, and it changes every week. Even so, the dates it prints for the four closed restaurants line up with the island's late-fall calendar closely enough to plan around.
Date | What changes | Where |
|---|---|---|
November 11 | Billie's on Broad reopens | 20 Broad Street |
November 18 | Boarding House and The Pearl reopen | 12 Federal Street |
November 23 | Festival of Wreaths preview party, 5 to 7 p.m. | Macy Warehouse, 12 Straight Wharf |
November 24 | Ethos reopens; Festival of Wreaths opens to the public | 18 Broad Street; 12 Straight Wharf |
November 26 | Cold Turkey Plunge, Thanksgiving morning at 10 a.m. | Children's Beach |
November 27 | Tree Lighting and Community Caroling, 4 p.m. | Downtown |
December 4 | Festival of Trees opens | Whaling Museum |
December 4 to 6 | Christmas Stroll | Downtown |
December 5 | Festival of Wreaths closes | 12 Straight Wharf |
The Nantucket Atheneum hosts the Cold Turkey Plunge, and the Nantucket Chamber of Commerce lists the Tree Lighting for the Friday after Thanksgiving. Read top to bottom, the table shows a downtown that fills back in a week at a time. Broad Street and Federal Street are back to their full lineup by the Tuesday of Thanksgiving week, and Straight Wharf gains a new attraction that same day.
Who's cooking in the meantime
On the October 19 to 25 sheet, more than fifty kitchens are open, counting sit-down and takeout together. A good share of them sit well away from the cobblestones, and one road does an unusual amount of the work.
Old South Road shows up six times on the list. Nantucket Bake Shop at 17½ opens at 6:30 a.m. Tuesday through Saturday. Nantucket Meat & Fish at 21 runs 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. Yezzi's at 57 serves 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. every day but Sunday. Salvadorena Food & Market at 63B opens at 6:30 a.m. on weekdays and stays open until 8 p.m. Thai House at 118 serves lunch and dinner. Fusaro's at 17 handles dinner every night except Sunday. Between them, that one corridor covers breakfast through dinner six days a week without anyone parking downtown.
The rest of the mid-island coverage is spread across a few clusters:
- Orange Street: Island Blend at 149 serves lunch and dinner, Henry, Jr. Sandwich Shop at 129 runs 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. except Sundays, and Roastd General Store at 159 opens at 6 a.m.
- Amelia Drive and Chin's Way: Pip and Anchor at 14 Amelia Drive is open Tuesday through Sunday, Siam @ the Hive at 5 Amelia Drive does weekday dinner from 4 to 8 p.m., and Island Kitchen at 2 Chin's Way serves breakfast and lunch seven days a week plus dinner Tuesday through Saturday.
- West Creek Road: Kitty Murtaugh's at 4 serves lunch and dinner, and Pi Pizzeria at 11 does the same except on Tuesdays.
- Surfside Road and the airport: 45 Surfside Bakery opens at 6:30 a.m., Muse Pizza at 44 runs until 1 a.m., and Crosswinds at the Airport serves all three meals.
Roastd also runs locations at 10 Airport Road, 31 Sparks Avenue and 33 Bartlett Farm Road, and the Airport Road shop stays open until 5 p.m.
The Monday problem
Monday is when the gaps show. The Dive, Downyflake, Sister Ship, Pip and Anchor and Company of the Cauldron all list Monday as a day off, and Nautilus skips dinner that night. Gaslight, Via Mare and Ventuno close Sunday through Tuesday. As of that late-October sheet, a Monday dinner had a shorter list of reliable options: Bar Yoshi and O Bar on Old South Wharf, both marked "Dinner 7 nites," along with Brotherhood of Thieves at 23 Broad Street, Rose and Crown at 23 South Water Street, Easy Street Restaurant, Toppers at 120 Wauwinet Road, and Lola 41 at 15 South Beach Street. For breakfast, Nobadeer Café at 1 Miller Lane runs 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. daily, and Island Coffee at 4 Broad Street opens at 5:30 a.m.
Three addresses that read differently this year
Part of the reason this November's sheet looks unfamiliar is that 2026 reshuffled several well-known addresses.
Café 22, 22 Federal Street. Jonas Baker opened Café 22 in February in the former Corner Table space. The Inquirer and Mirror reported that it launched with seven-day hours from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. and a stated goal of employing locals year-round and serving the off-season community. On the late-October sheet it keeps the same hours but closes on Tuesdays. It's the first fall for a café built around the off-season.
The Dive, 15 South Water Street. The former Charlie Noble space had been dark since fall 2024. Nantucket Current reported that The Dive opened there as a partnership between Boston's Sneaky Good Hospitality Group and island restaurateur Denise Corson. It's still on the October list, serving lunch Friday through Sunday and dinner Tuesday through Sunday.
27 Fairgrounds Road. Nantucket Current reported that Downyflake owners Pate Kennedy and Ron Oldham sold the business, brand and assets to Ethan and Alexis Devine, who own The Fairgrounds. The Town sheet now lists both names at the same address, and the hours fit together. Downyflake serves breakfast with table service and takeout and closes Mondays. The Fairgrounds serves lunch on weekends and dinner Wednesday through Sunday. One mid-island building now covers most of the day, most days of the week.
The Tavern and The Gazebo, the open-sided bar with harbor views, closed permanently on October 12 after 34 seasons, when the lease was not renewed. Boston.com reported, citing the Current, that a Gazebo sign now hangs in the "Penalty Box" area of The Chicken Box on Dave Street. It also reported that proceeds from selling the restaurant's red tables, chairs and other belongings were going to Addiction Solutions of Nantucket. In the same coverage, the owner told the Current: "I brought the mudslide to the Gazebo back in 1993, and this will be the last year of my formula and my mudslide as we've all got to know it."
Straight Wharf, rearranged for December
The Gazebo's closing leaves a gap at the harbor end of downtown just as the NHA brings that stretch back to life. The NHA announced that its 28th annual Festival of Wreaths will move to the historic Macy Warehouse at 12 Straight Wharf, displayed on the building's second floor for the first time, with free admission. The move also stretches the festival beyond its usual Thanksgiving-week run to nearly two weeks, from November 24 to December 5, so it now overlaps with Stroll weekend and the opening of the Festival of Trees at the Whaling Museum on December 4. Marine Home Center is the lead sponsor, the wreaths come from islanders, local businesses, nonprofits, schools and community organizations, and bidding also runs online.
That puts a free, indoor stop on Straight Wharf for every day from Ethos's reopening through the Saturday of the Stroll. Food is within a short walk. bACKyard Barbecue at 20 Straight Wharf was serving lunch and dinner on the October sheet, Straight Wharf Fish at 4 Harbor Square was open 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. except Wednesdays, and Jack and Charlie's at 10 Straight Wharf opens at 7 a.m. Up the hill, the Whaling Museum and its Museum Shop are open Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., through December 31, except on Thanksgiving, November 26, when the NHA is closed. Hadwen House and the NHA's other historic sites have closed for the 2026 season, though their grounds and gardens stay open until dusk.
Where the weekly sheet lives
The dates above come from a document the Town publishes for exactly this stretch of the year. According to the Town of Nantucket's FAQ, Visitor Services tracks open restaurants week by week between Labor Day and June 1, and keeps a book of menus at its office year-round. The edition used here is the October 19 to 25 sheet, updated October 23, and newer weekly editions will follow it. Any restaurant's hours can change from one week to the next, and the reopening dates for Billie's, Boarding House, The Pearl and Ethos are what the Town printed that week, not a guarantee from the restaurants.
Each sheet also shows small details that change with the season: which kitchens list a phone number and which list none, which have dropped lunch, and which mention delivery through ACKeats.com. The Boathouse, Scooters, Stubby's and Walter's Deli all carry that delivery note on the current sheet. Stubby's at 8 Broad Street stays open until 2 a.m. on Friday and Saturday.
I live and work on the same seasonal calendar as my clients, and the weeks before the Stroll are when the island is easiest to see clearly. If you're thinking about Nantucket over the coming months, whether you're keeping a place, adding one or letting one go, Matthew Winterle is glad to talk through how the off-season looks from up close. Contact Matthew.